Key takeaways
- Grills perform the same on either fuel. Each is built with the correct burner orifices for its gas.
- Natural gas means no tank swaps and usually a lower cost per hour of grilling, but the gas line adds installation cost.
- Propane works anywhere and is quicker to set up, but you will need a spare tank and a ventilated place to store it.
- Order the appliance in the fuel you will use. Conversions are possible on many models but should be done by a qualified technician.
The basic difference
Natural gas (NG) arrives through a permanent utility line. Liquid propane (LP) is stored as a liquid in a refillable tank. Propane carries much more energy per cubic foot than natural gas, so the two fuels are delivered at different pressures and through differently sized orifices. That is why a grill is built (or converted) specifically for one fuel.
Once it is set up correctly, a grill cooks the same on either fuel. BTU ratings, searing ability and cooking results do not change in any way you will notice.
Side-by-side comparison
| Natural gas | Propane | |
|---|---|---|
| Supply | Permanent line; never runs out | 20 lb tanks (or a larger fixed tank); needs refills |
| Upfront cost | Higher: a licensed plumber runs and sizes the line | Lower: connect a tank and go |
| Running cost | Usually lower per hour in most areas | Usually higher per hour; varies with local prices |
| Placement | Limited by where the line can run | Anywhere a tank can be stored safely |
| Storage | None needed | Ventilated tank drawer or cabinet |
| Best for | Permanent kitchens near an existing gas service | Islands far from the house, carts, phased projects |
How long does a propane tank last?
A standard 20 lb tank holds roughly 4.7 gallons of propane, or about 430,000 BTU of energy. A grill running all burners on high at 60,000 BTU per hour would empty it in about seven hours, but most cooking happens at medium or low with only some burners lit, so real-world use is usually much longer. Large grills, side burners and pizza ovens on the same tank will shorten that time.
Installation and safety
- Natural gas lines must be sized for the combined BTU load of every appliance on them (grill, side burner, pizza oven, fire pit) and for the length of the run. Undersized lines cause weak flames. This is a job for a licensed professional.
- Propane tanks need ventilation. Propane is heavier than air, so a leak settles low. Islands with an enclosed propane space should have vent panels, and most manufacturers require them.
- Never store a propane tank directly under a built-in grill head unless the appliance and island are designed for it, and keep spare tanks outdoors.
- Check local codes and permits. Many areas require permits and inspections for gas line work.
Can you convert later?
Many built-in grills and side burners can be converted between NG and LP with a manufacturer kit (orifices and sometimes a regulator), and some ship with the opposite-fuel kit in the box. Not every model allows it, and a conversion should always be done by a qualified technician. If you are unsure which fuel you will end up with, check conversion support on the model before you buy.
Which should you choose?
If natural gas is already at your home and the kitchen is permanent, NG is usually the better long-term choice: no tank swaps and lower running cost. If the island is far from the house, you are building in phases, or you want the option to move the grill, propane is simpler and costs less to start. Either way, the quality of the grill matters far more than the fuel. Our built-in gas grill buying guide covers what to look for.




